Anonymous1: @Silent_Witness: Makes sense with this particular design, since it's less on-model and more realistic in general. But otherwise having perfectly realistic, detailed genitals on show accurate style is wrong.
Silent_Witness: @Gomenasai: I can understand the point made here and with this specific art style, but I don't understand why this is such a contested issue. Remember the debate on this image? I just don't get why, out of all the unrealistic aspects of the ponies, this one gets so much focus.
Anonymous2(1): @Silent_Witness: It's something that's up to imagination, because the show confirms that ponies have genitalia but doesn't ever show it. And everyone has wildly different ideas of their canon form.
Bud given how simplistic the style is I'd say it's very well represented here: >>916703 Fits perfectly with the style and looks believable. I'd like to see a penis done like this.
Roflcakes: Horse cocks are FINE and considered perfectly normal but when you draw a horse cunt on a vague, cartoon representation of a horse you're RUINING EVERYTHING?
bAv-R34: @ConsciousDonkey: Over a Barrel, Pinkie is holding her crotch because she is in desperate need of a piss, and Applejack is seen walking out of an outhouse after a flush is heard.
Speaking of which, in Winter Wrap Up, Spike says that Twilight's bird nest looks like an outhouse, which confirms that they at least have toilets, otherwise he would not have known what an outhouse was.
ConsciousDonkey: @bAv-R34: No, that tells the children that because the characters drink and eat, they also have to pee and poo. There are absolutely no sexual/genitalia overtones in the scenes you cite.
Anonymous5(1): @ConsciousDonkey: If that isn't enough there's also Baby Cakes and all that talk Mr. Cake gives about genetics and how unicorn and pegasus genes have passed in their family, which also proves that foals don't come from storks. And then there's Word of Faust herself confirming it, as she indeed said ponies breed the natural way.
ConsciousDonkey: @Gomenasai: Oh. Okay. I don't read MLP news/gossip sites like Equestria Daily, so I will take your word for it. Besides, it sounds kinda logical.
ConsciousDonkey: @Gomenasai: Hmm, that got me wondering: how was this "where the babies come from" question dealt with in previous MLP generations? Did they really use the "stork explanation"?
As for the content, well, personally I like the "realistic" type better, but that is only because I find that, in general, it is drawn better whereas human genitals on ponies are mostly featured in bad pictures. Generally both is fine.
Silent_Witness: @Gomenasai: I can't provide a source unfortunately, but I know that in one of the previous generations, babies were formed via a magic mirror, where a pony who wanted a baby would go to it and wish for one.
I really wish I was kidding about that.
- Reply
- Reply
Bud given how simplistic the style is I'd say it's very well represented here: >>916703
Fits perfectly with the style and looks believable. I'd like to see a penis done like this.
- Reply
- Reply
Yeah, great logic there...
- Reply
Zoophiles EVRYWHERE.
- Reply
- Reply
Where? Which episode? I don't remember a single hint about that in the show.
- Reply
Speaking of which, in Winter Wrap Up, Spike says that Twilight's bird nest looks like an outhouse, which confirms that they at least have toilets, otherwise he would not have known what an outhouse was.
- Reply
- Reply
- Reply
As for the content, well, personally I like the "realistic" type better, but that is only because I find that, in general, it is drawn better whereas human genitals on ponies are mostly featured in bad pictures. Generally both is fine.
- Reply
I really wish I was kidding about that.